What Happened To Vinnie Pasquantino's Power?

Vinnie Pasquantino's season is a reminder that controlling the strike zone is not enough when a hitter loses the ability to impact the baseball. He continues to make the decisions you'd expect from a middle-of-the-order hitter, but those decisions no longer produce the same kind of contact. The Royals first baseman rarely chases pitches outside the zone, owns a solid 11.0% walk rate, and makes contact on more than 90% of the pitches he sees in the strike zone. The swing that turned that disciplined approach into legitimate power over the past few seasons, however, is no longer producing the same results.

Pasquantino's decline in bat speed has changed how left-handed pitchers can attack him. Against lefties, Pasquantino averages just 66.5 mph in bat speed—ranking in the fifth percentile across Major League Baseball. That has given opposing pitchers far more freedom to challenge him up and in or work the lower part of the strike zone without taking the same risks they once did. Pitches that previously demanded precise execution can now be thrown with much greater confidence because Pasquantino takes longer to get the barrel to the ball.

The heat map illustrates that vulnerability. Outside of two quadrants in the upper portion of the strike zone, nearly the entire chart is shaded blue against left-handed pitching, including the area tight to his hands and much of the lower zone. Pitchers no longer need to live on the edges of the strike zone. They can attack him directly because that swing no longer punishes those pitches.

The change is also evident in the type of contact he produces. Pasquantino still puts the ball in play, but he no longer moves the barrel through the zone with enough acceleration to transfer the same amount of energy at contact. The swing that once produced authoritative pulled fly balls to right field has largely disappeared against left-handed pitching. His PullAir% has fallen to 17.3%, while only 1.8% of his swings now qualify as Blast Swings.

The split tells the story:

Against right-handed pitching, Pasquantino still looks like the middle-of-the-order hitter the Royals expected, posting a .357 xwOBA alongside a 45.8% Hard-Hit rate. Against lefties, the profile changes completely. The drop in impact explains the rest of his offensive line: his Hard-Hit rate falls to 22.0%, barrels nearly disappear (1.7%), and his isolated power (ISO) has fallen from .211 to .113 compared to last season. Even his maximum exit velocity has declined from 114.4 mph to 108.1 mph. The change is also visible in his batted-ball profile, as 16.7% of his fly balls never even leave the infield.

Pasquantino's season serves as a reminder that controlling the strike zone alone is not enough to sustain power. His plate discipline has returned to an elite level. The problem begins only after he decides to swing. As long as that physical gap remains, he'll continue to build quality plate appearances and lay off pitches he can't drive. What he can no longer guarantee—especially against left-handed pitching—is the kind of contact that makes a power-hitting first baseman the centerpiece of an offense and the hitter capable of changing a game with a single swing.

Do you approve of the job Matt Quatraro is doing as Royals manager?

Do you approve of the job Matt Quatraro is doing as Royals manager?

• Do you approve of the job Matt Quatraro is doing as Royals manager? Required
  

  
• Save

See All Royals Polls >