Royals Video
Logan Evans’ last pitch with the Seattle Mariners in the major leagues was a high-and-tight 92.2-mph sinker against Andy Pages, who hit a fly ball deep into left field at T-Mobile Park to close out the bottom of the eighth inning on September 27, 2025. That night, Evans made his 16th start of the season, but his first and only appearance as a reliever, working three innings and allowing a run that tied the score at three in the top of the seventh inning.
That would end up being his last game before missing the entire 2026 season due to a tear in the ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) in his right elbow, which required surgery on January 23 of this year. The problem began in 2025, when he was placed on the injured list due to inflammation in that elbow. Although he returned in September, the discomfort eventually required a UCL repair with an internal brace, with the recovery process estimated at approximately 12 months.
Often, when young pitchers go through these processes, it becomes difficult to evaluate their trends because you never know for certain how much an injury may have affected their performance for the rest of the season. The final reports may indicate that the pitcher has recovered and the player himself may feel 100%, but that does not necessarily mean he has left behind all the effects of the injury. In Evans’ case, when analyzing his 2025 performance, we can draw several conclusions, one of which is the inconsistency he showed in maintaining control of his pitches.
Evans issued at least one walk in 15 of his 16 appearances and, in at least nine of them, struck out three or fewer batters and allowed a home run. That inconsistency sums up his final results quite well, with a limited 6.53 K/9, 3.43 BB/9, and 13.0% HR/FB rate, three vulnerabilities that led Evans to post a 4.87 xFIP. There is clearly a fairly notable difference between the MLB level and the minors, but the version of Evans we saw in 2025 was not far from what he had recently shown in Double-A during the 2024 season, when he finished with a 9-5 record and a 3.20 ERA in 107 innings.
Evans finished the year with rates close to the ones he recorded in MLB, with an 8.24 K/9 and 3.53 BB/9, along with an allowed BABIP of .264, slightly below the .284 he recorded with the Mariners. That said, the big difference was in the HR/FB rate, which went to 8.3% when he moved up a level and pitched 44 innings in Triple-A during 2025, before eventually reaching 13.0% in MLB.
I know there will not be much discussion if we compare Evans with other young pitchers who reached the majors over the last four seasons with the Mariners and had a greater impact, such as George Kirby (debuted in 2022), Bryan Woo (2023), Emerson Hancock (2023) and Bryce Miller (2023), who was part of the trade that sent him to Kansas City. However, there is one detail they all have in common: their problems during the early stretch of their careers, in their first 15 starts.
Kirby was the most consistent, with a 3.40 ERA, the highest K-BB% rate, and the second-best home run rate. As you can see, Evans was around the group’s average in ERA, strikeouts, and home runs allowed, but his control problems resurfaced, with the highest walk rate. Of course, that was only a comparative reference and, while all the pitchers in the group moved forward, Evans will have to recover his career after overcoming the injuries that have kept him off the field for more than one season.
When he returns, I think one of the big expectations surrounding Evans will be seeing how much velocity his arm shows and what changes he could implement in his arsenal, which featured six types of pitches in 2025: cutter, sweeper, sinker, changeup, four-seam fastball, and a curveball that he used 18% of the time against left-handed batters and only 2% against right-handers. Here we enter another interesting area, as Evans will have a lot to adjust after finishing in the 12th percentile in Pitching run value during the 2025 season, with only two grades above the 50th percentile: 96 in Curve Spin and 57 in Offspeed.
Regarding his arsenal, there are several critical points worth highlighting, but I will divide the analysis into “expectations,” since there are some pitches he will definitely have to readjust or could eliminate. Also, I think this can work to analyze Evans against both profiles, as he faced a similar number of right-handed (176) and left-handed (174) batters. What is most surprising is that both produced a very similar impact, with .338 and .339 wOBA, respectively.
Evans' Cutter
Analysis Scale: B+
What works and what should change? It was one of his most effective pitches, especially against right-handed batters, with a +5 Run Value and a 24.1% Whiff%, although its induced vertical movement is 5.8 inches below the MLB average.
Evans' Changeup
Analysis Scale: B+
What works and what should change? It is one of the most promising pitches in his arsenal and the best weapon he showed for dominating left-handed batters. It was not a pitch capable of generating a high rate of swings and misses (it recorded a 19.4% whiff rate), but it limited hard contact to a 20% Hard Hit rate and left the league with a .232 xwOBA.
Evans' Sweeper
Analysis Scale: C+
What works and what should change? I think it gives me a little hope to see that it has 14.3 inches of induced horizontal movement, but its results were not reliable against right-handed batters, which led to a -2 Run Value and a .351 xwOBA.
Evans' Sinker
Analysis Scale: D
What works and what should change? If it were not for the fact that Evans’ fastball has also been unable to provide the necessary impact to become a reliable pitch, I would place the sinker among the pitches he should avoid against right-handed batters, who averaged a 48% Hard Hit%. In addition, it generated just an 8.8% swing-and-miss rate.
Evans' 4-Seam Fastball
Analysis Scale: D
What works and what should change? The average velocity was just 92.8 mph, which generated quite a few problems for Evans when he tried to attack the strike zone. His opponents hit .630 slugging against it, and he recorded just a 6.1 K%, the lowest among all his pitches. If we combine Evans’ results with the sinker and the fastball, two of the highest-velocity pitches that should generate a significant impact for a 24-year-old pitcher, the Whiff rate drops to 11.8%, with a 1.0 K-BB% and an allowed .488 xSLG.
Evans only found life when he combined his sinker and fastball in the upper third of the strike zone or managed to get batters to chase pitches outside the zone, but he was not consistent enough to get more out of them. The big problem went beyond his fastball and sinker: in general, Evans fell below the league average, with 25.2 O-Swing% and 82.5 Contact%, while pitchers recorded 31.5% and 76.9%, respectively, in 2025.
Evans' Curveball
Analysis Scale: D-
What works and what should change? I don’t think I am a big fan of his curveball for fairly obvious reasons: it was punished with a .691 xSLG and a 51.6% Hard Hit rate, figures that led to a -7 Run Value.
The effect was quite similar to that of fastballs and sinkers, with a stronger impact in the upper third, but when he tried to enter the zone, batters frequently crushed it.
For now, we look forward to seeing how Evans takes a step forward and perhaps competes for a spot in the Royals’ rotation in 2027. But if he does not achieve it, he will still have the challenge of getting back on the mound, recovering his competitive form, and proving that he can become a reliable option for Kansas City’s pitching staff.
Want to play the role of Royals general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Royals roster!
Build Your 2027 Roster




Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now