Jump to content
Royals Keep
Posted

Finding arms who could improve the starting rotation was the type of move the Royals were looking for this winter, and they have just accomplished it, although it cost them their regular third baseman, Maikel Garcia, who was sent to Seattle along with reliever James McArthur and prospect L.P. Langevin in exchange for starters Bryce Miller and Logan Evans, as well as left-handed reliever Jose A. Ferrer.

Garcia, 26, won the Gold Glove last year in the best season of his career, recording career highs in home runs (16), RBIs (74), batting average (.286), on-base percentage (.351), slugging (.449), xwOBA (.348), and fWAR (5.8). However, he suffered a right hamstring strain in May that forced him to miss six games and, later, a muscle injury in his left hand that kept him out for 46 games.

After returning in August, he suffered another strain, this time in his left hamstring, which kept him out for another 21 games. After three seasons recording at least 123 games played, he ended up playing just 82 this year and saw his wRC+ fall from 120 to 99, moving quite far away from his impact in 2025. While dealing with injuries was not easy, especially when it came to hitting, Garcia was once again inconsistent against right-handed pitchers, producing just 80 wRC+, with his slugging falling from .500 against left-handers to just .345. This has been a problem Garcia has carried since arriving in the major leagues in 2022, and since then, he has averaged just 86 wRC+, with a .255/.313/.360 slash line and .673 OPS against right-handed pitchers, unlike his consistent performance against left-handers, with 121 wRC+ and .804 OPS.

image.png

That said, Garcia’s departure reshapes expectations in the Royals’ infield, where Nick Loftin could now find an opportunity to become a starting player for next season. Now, the question is whether Kansas City will trust Loftin to fill Garcia’s void, especially on offense, which has been the weakest point of his career.

Loftin has played four seasons with the Royals, but this year was the first time he was able to find opportunities and ended up playing 118 games, 64% of them as a third baseman (he appeared in 75 games), covering Garcia’s absence. He also functioned as a kind of utility player, as he had appearances at first base (2 games), second base (36), left field (3), and right field (3). As a third baseman, he recorded +6 DRS in 582 ⅔ innings, in addition to +6 OAA and +5 FRV, a performance that led him to earn inclusion among the Gold Glove finalists.

Up to this point, there is no doubt that Loftin has enough ability to do the defensive job, but expectations change when the offensive side enters the conversation, although it is fair to point out that he was a good baserunner in 2026, finishing in the 79th percentile in Base Running. Loftin also had good plate discipline, as he does not usually record high chase rates, strikes out little, and finished in the 84th percentile in Whiff%. The problem starts for one reason alone, and it is after he makes contact, when he produces a low percentage of hard-hit balls.

In 2026, Loftin’s Barrel rate dropped from 6.3 in 2025 to 4.2, and he failed to get past the 18th percentile in xBA (18), xSLG (11), EV (13), Barrel% (18), and Hard Hit% (11), despite hitting 37 extra-base hits (27 of them were doubles), a figure that surpassed the 26 he had accumulated in three seasons before 2026. Granted, this year’s Loftin, who finished with a .276 BABIP and 98 wRC+, is a much more complete hitter than the one who averaged a .248 BABIP and 72 wRC+ between 2023 and 2025, but he is still far from providing the offensive value that could come close to the stability Garcia offered when he was healthy.

Look, I still think Loftin has something valuable in his favor, and that is the fact that he can make contact, but regardless of the work he will have to do to produce harder-hit balls that can find the gaps and take advantage of the park effect at Kauffman Stadium, there are another couple of pending assignments:

1. Solve his problems against right-handed pitchers, which have limited him to just a .246 BABIP and 75 wRC+ in 541 plate appearances, enough at-bats to put a new plan into motion.

2. Work on his aggressive approach against breaking pitches from right-handed pitchers, which have taken him to the abyss throughout his career.

In 2026, 55% of Loftin’s strikeouts came against breaking pitches, but the worst part was that he recorded a batting average of just .171 and .186 xBA, which once again corroborates the low expectations for his batted balls. Of course, there is a strong possibility that Loftin will improve, as is usually the case with hitters who finally change their aggressive approach and work to better identify pitches and, above all, stop chasing pitches outside the strike zone.

Let’s take a look at these charts that include Loftin’s career trends against breaking pitches from right-handed pitchers.

image.jpeg

As you can appreciate, his chase problems are evident against pitches that move away toward the lower part of the outside corner. The percentage of pitches his opponents throw to that area is 42.6%, almost half of the breaking pitches, and the whiff percentage is 68.6%. It is likely that you have also noticed the hot zones: the pitches that have stayed hanging right down the middle or in the inner part of the zone; Loftin has never missed them and averages .500 or more in both parts of the zone.

When pitches move away, the missed swings arrive, and the averages fall, although in the portion located in the upper third, where he was thrown fewer pitches, he also added a little heat. The location of that type of pitch fits perfectly with his decrease from -5 to -16 in Shadow Run Value, so it will be interesting to see how much Loftin’s contact could improve, although the fact that he stops chasing does not guarantee an improvement in his exit velocities if he manages to hit more often in the strike zone.

I do not completely rule out that the Royals are thinking about looking for a better hitter who can take care of third base, but they will probably offer Loftin a vote of confidence. If so, let’s hope he can take advantage of it.

Image courtesy of Denny Medley-Imagn Images

View full article

Recommended Posts

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Royals Keep Caretaker Fund
The Royals Keep Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Royals community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Royals Keep.

×
×
  • Create New...